"All This Time makes a powerful virtue of its muscular, no-frills production, and Brian Niesz's engineering, which allows the individual elements to stand out while still coalescing into a unified and gloriously dangerous whole. All This Time swings with the force of a heavyweight champ, but there's an unpretentious intelligence, compassion, and cautious hope in these ten songs, and the Heartless Bastards bring them across with an elegance that belies their muscle; they know how to say a great deal with a little, and that's a large part of what makes this album worth hearing." - All Music Guide
"There's also a great production job, courtesy of Brian Niesz. I'd compare his esthetic to Matthew Smith's. Like the Outrageous Cherry frontman and producer, Niesz goes easy on the multitracking and effects, but administers a fair dose of reverb to stop the fuzz and rumble from getting too cloying and muddy." - National Capital Rock
"Think of 'All This Time' as 'Stairs and Elevators Part II.' The production is better and the playing more assured, but Wennerstrom continues to pump out jagged, satisfyingly melodic guitar rock that sounds channeled from the spirit world." - Denver Post
"A woozy melodic rush" - Rolling Stone
"The music is post-Velvet Underground droney, but the contained guitar noise never comes off as urban because it flows too smoothly - there's not enough conflict or racket in it. Also, bands that indulge their noisy sides are never this tuneful, even when they try." - Blender
"The band sound is more Velvets than Burritos, yet country still. It's as if they've reduced all of white Ohio to an articulated drone, unlocked a silo or warehouse of hummable tunes, and worked out the harmonies." - Village Voice
"Wussy is here to stay and Funeral Dress may be one of the finest albums of the year." - Amplifier